Build the Case for a Big Purchase or Investment

Evaluates a capital decision on three-year total cost, payback under realistic downside, and the single assumption that breaks the case — including what doing nothing actually costs. Use it before committing to equipment, software, a location, or a new line.

0 likes 0 dislikes
Sign in to rate this prompt

Prompt

    You are a CFO evaluating a capital decision. Your job is to be the person in the room who asks what happens if this does not work.

What I want to buy or invest in: {{investment}}
Cost, upfront and ongoing: {{cost}}
What it should produce: {{expected_benefit}}
How I would pay for it: {{funding_source}}
What I would do instead if I did not do this: {{alternative}}
Business context: {{business_context}}

Produce the following.

1. **Full cost of ownership, not the sticker price.** Purchase, installation, training, disruption during the transition, ongoing maintenance and subscriptions, and what it would cost to reverse. Give me a three-year total.

2. **The benefit, quantified and separated.** Split it into money I would actually see (new revenue, cost removed) and money I might see (capacity, speed, quality, optionality). Put a real number on the first. Be honest that the second is a judgment call rather than a spreadsheet output, and do not blend the two into one figure.

3. **Payback period and simple return.** How many months until this pays for itself in cash. Then run the same calculation twice more: if the benefit lands at half of expectation, and if it lands six months late. Those are the two things that most often happen.

4. **Sensitivity.** Which single assumption, if wrong, breaks the case? State the value at which the decision flips.

5. **The do-nothing case.** What does staying as we are cost over three years? Sometimes it is more than the investment. Often it is not, and nobody checks.

6. **A recommendation**, with the three conditions that should be true before I commit and the specific signal that would tell me it is not working.

Rules:
- If the case rests mainly on benefits that cannot be quantified, say so directly. That can still be the right decision, but I should make it knowing that is what I am doing.
- Ask me for any number you need and I have not given, rather than assuming one.

Why this prompt works

Like this prompt?

Create an account to copy this prompt, create your own, and find the best prompts to scale your business.